Posted on

Public Policy Debate Over the Lottery

The lottery is a game in which participants purchase tickets for a chance to win a prize, often money. The odds of winning are based on the number of tickets purchased and the size of the prize. A prize can also be goods, services or real estate. Some states run their own lotteries, while others license private corporations to organize and operate them. Lotteries are an important source of public revenue and can provide an alternative to raising taxes or cutting government programs. But the public policy debate over state-sponsored lotteries has largely overlooked the ethical issues raised by this type of gambling.

Since 1964, when New Hampshire established the first state-run lottery, 37 states have followed suit and now have one or more lotteries. But despite the differences among the different state lotteries, they all follow similar patterns: a state legislates a monopoly for itself; creates an agency or public corporation to run it (rather than licensing a private firm in return for a share of the profits); begins operations with a small number of relatively simple games; and, due to pressure for additional revenues, gradually expands its offerings to include more and more complex games.

In the early days of state lotteries, they were widely viewed as a form of hidden tax. In the post-World War II period, however, lotteries became a major way that many states raised funds to support their expanding array of government services without significantly increasing state tax rates. This arrangement helped to ease concerns over state budget deficits and allowed the expansion of social safety-net benefits that had previously been financed by general taxation.

Nevertheless, the growth of state lotteries has not been without controversy. Some state lawmakers have objected to the regressivity of lottery revenues and complained that the industry’s promotion of gambling is at cross-purposes with the legitimate function of state governments. Others have questioned the morality of a system that offers such high prizes to people with no special skills or abilities, and especially in an era of growing income inequality and declining social mobility.

While it is impossible to know the exact percentage of the population that plays the lottery, it is safe to say that the majority comes from middle-income neighborhoods and a proportionally smaller percentage of those from low-income communities. In addition, as the numbers indicate, lotteries are overwhelmingly popular in times of economic stress and when state governments are under financial pressure.

Lotteries have been around for centuries. The first records of them are from the Low Countries in the 15th century, where they were used to raise money for town fortifications and for charitable purposes. In colonial America, the lottery was used to finance everything from paving streets and constructing wharves to supplying Benjamin Franklin with cannons to defend Philadelphia against the British. The lottery’s popularity rose and fell with the state’s fiscal health, but it remained a staple of American life. It remains a popular and controversial method for raising public revenue.